Christopher Browne cbbrowne
Thu Jan 13 15:35:39 PST 2005
David Parker wrote:

>There was some discussion recently on this list about whether a 1.0.6 release was in the offing or not. Apart from the specific issue (min XID, I think it was), are there other fixes to 1.0.5 waiting in the wings to go out? 
>
>I am still at 1.0.2, and getting ready to move to 1.0.5, but if 1.0.6 is in the pipeline, then maybe I'll wait. 
>
>Also, are there critical reasons to move from 1.0.2 to 1.0.5, apart from just wanting to be current? I haven't run into any problems, but I have a pretty simple topology (about to become significantly more complex), and have not had serious performance testing....
>  
>
The particular problem that caused me to "wonder aloud" if 1.0.6 might 
be necessary turned out to relate to an application error.  (Simply 
put:  Long running transactions are evil.  Long running <IDLE> in 
transaction is, because it is more nearly invisible, REALLY evil...)

So I don't expect 1.0.6 is imminent.

I would suggest that you go ahead with 1.0.5; there are rather a lot of 
little improvements in it that "add up." 

- The cleanup thread (recently at issue) is _way_ improved in 1.0.5 over 
1.0.2.  And if you're planning to increase the topology of your network, 
the improvements to cleanup are very significant.

- If you ever have slons fall down due to servers falling over, 1.0.5 
copes with restarting them MUCH better; where, in 1.0.2, you might have 
to manually intervene to do a "RESET NODE", 1.0.5 does some config 
cleanup at start time.

- It took us quite a while to get all the testing done to get 1.0.5 into 
place; the "mantra" that kept getting recited nearly every time an issue 
came up was "Oh, that's fixed in 1.0.5."


More information about the Slony1-general mailing list